Pull Apart Christmas Tree Garlic Bread.
Our 2021 Holiday Cookie Box…along with some tips and tricks to help you create the perfect cookie box at home! This year’s box is filled to the top with all of our most favorite Christmas cookies and bars. Some new…and some of our old favorites. There’s everything from classics…like snickerdoodles and gingery brown sugar molasses cookies. To Christmas monster cookies and the cutest little tree light cookies, plus a handful more. We’re packing up only the very BEST cookies and sweets this holiday season. There’s no better gift than a box full of homemade cookies, they are always enjoyed!
After a lot of requests, this year’s 2021 Holiday Cookie Box is finally here! I can’t believe the amount of people who’ve messaged me regarding this year’s box. I’m a little late (what’s new, we seem to always be late on things over here). But it’s so nice to see the excitement around these boxes. I always have a lot fun putting these together. It’s by far my favorite “tradition” I get to share with you guys every December. But man they do take some time to create. I think I spent two full days baking and photographing this box, I really wanted it to be just right! You guys make it worth though, and as I said above, they really do make the best gifts!
I’ve loved all my previous holiday cookie boxes (see my boxes from 2017, 2018, 2019, and 2020), but I wanted to make this one even more special.
What’s exciting is that this year we are back to celebrating with family and friends. Which means that many of us are traveling this season. Thankfully, cookie boxes are the perfect gift to bring along, whether you have a long or short journey. Showing up empty handed to any gathering is never ideal, but showing up with a cookie box?
Well, there’s really not a better gift.
And of course, if you still aren’t able to see friends and family this holiday season, ship them a cookie box. Or drop a box off at their doorstep. It’s the sweetest way to let them know you’re thinking of them.
This year’s box is in keeping with my “easy cookies” theme of the month. At the end of November, I said that I wouldn’t be sharing any tricky or overly decorated cookies. Because when it comes to holiday baking – easy and fun is 100% the way to go!
So, this year I made all my favorite, easy, but oh so delicious cookies. I’ve learned a few tips and tricks over the years, so I’m sharing all the details below!
When choosing your cookies, be sure to pick cookies, and or other desserts, that will hold up well in shipping. I like to choose cookies that are of different shapes and sizes. I find it’s nice to have a little variety in the box. Normally I’ll bake anywhere from four to eight different cookies and then divide them between boxes. This year I did eight different cookies and made a nice size box.
With that said, my box is large. Many of you will most likely be using smaller boxes. If that’s the case, just go with four to six of your favorite cookies.
All the cookies used in my 2021 Holiday Cookie Box:
Brown Sugar Maple Ginger Cookies (i let the glaze dry, then add to the box, but you can leave the glaze off too)
Easy Vanilla Bean Christmas Lights Cookies (tip, add 2 teaspoons meringue powder to the icing to help it harden and be better for packaging)
Salted Caramel Pretzel Snickerdoodles
Milk Chocolate and Peanut Butter Blondies (oldie but goodie HBH recipe)
Slice n’ Bake Salted Chocolate Butter Pecan Cookies
Chocolate Peanut Butter Crinkle Cookies
Chewy Brown Sugar Maple Cookies
The box you use to package your cookies is very important, especially if you’re shipping cookies overnight. You’ll want to choose a sturdy box that can handle shipping. I love using a heavy-duty cardboard box, think something like a nice hatbox. Then I like to add cardboard ornament dividers. Or simply make your own using cardboard from old Amazon packages, which is what I did for this year’s box. Dividers keep each cookie separate from one other. If you have a wooden box and are just gifting to someone close to home, that is great too!
If you’re looking to order a box, I found this cute Christmas box set which comes with cute paper, ribbon, and tags. There’s also this box with an ornament design. Or if you’re looking for a simpler design, these are nice too, but a little smaller.
Lastly, these cookie boxes with a gingerbread house design are adorable too. I recommend smaller treats for this box though!
Either of these boxes are the perfect size for gifting and will fit four to six different cookies. These boxes are great for dropping off to neighbors and gifting to family and friends in town. If you plan to ship your box, I’d recommend putting the cookie box inside a sturdier box. Be sure to use bubble wrap or packing paper to secure the box. This will ensure that none of your cookies get banged around during shipping.
Another alternative is to use cookie tins. I love these festive square tins or these more classic round tins.
Or, if you want to ship just one cookie, give this cookie box a try. It would be perfect for a batch of Hot Chocolate Lace Cookies.
Tip: place bubble wrap in the bottom of your box. Then line the box with a very large piece of plastic wrap (use multiple layers if needed). Be sure to use a piece that is large enough to wrap overtop of the cookies when the box is full. This keeps the cookies safe and fresh.
I try to find festive plastic wrapping, food-safe tissue paper, and/or ribbon to wrap around my cookies. This gives your box that extra special touch.
Tip: I always wrap cookies that I want to stay extra fresh in holiday ziplock storage bags and then add them to the box. If you want to use something a little cuter than storage bags or plastic wrap, try using holiday cellophane bags that can be sealed with ribbon. Or use small holiday cookie tins or boxes, or food containers that will fit inside your box.
As I mentioned above, I like to bake and decorate the cookies in the morning. Then I let them chill and package them up later that afternoon or at night. This way they are all ready to ship in the morning. Have fun and make a day of this with your girlfriends, kids, siblings, really anyone who loves to bake and listen to Christmas music!
Packing up your boxes is probably one of the trickiest steps of sending out holiday cookie boxes. You’ll want to make sure that all the time you spent making cookies wasn’t wasted. First, you should know that these photos are a bit misleading. They do not represent how I would actually ship my box. My goal is to show off the cookies, but here are my best tips for actually packaging up the cookies and shipping out your boxes…
I ship via UPS or Fed-Ex, I’ve found them to be pretty reliable. Ship your cookies via two-day air because it’s important to get your cookies to their recipient as soon as possible. My biggest tip? If possible, avoid the post office. In my experience, that does not end well.
question: What are all of you baking up this holiday season? What are your BEST tips in creating cookie boxes? Share all your tips in comments!
Lastly, if you make any of the cookies from our 2021 Holiday Cookie Box, be sure to leave a comment and/or give this recipe a rating! Above all, I love to hear from you guys and always do my best to respond to each and every comment. And of course, if you do make this recipe, don’t forget to tag me on Instagram! Looking through the photos of recipes you all have made is my favorite!
Hey, you’re AMAZING btw, thank you for sharing your love of cooking and baking. You mentioned today you made snickerdoodle bars, do you have a recipe for that?
Thank you so much Shelley! So sorry, I do not have a recipe just yet! Happy Holidays! xT
Can I still order a cookie box!!
The cookie boxes are not for order:) Happy Holidays! xx
Happy New Year!
I’m a little late but you’ve totally inspired me to make my very first cookie box for my boyfriend’s birthday later this month, since we can’t celebrate together this year. I’m planning on making 3 cookies from this list:
Christmas Monster Cookies
Brown Sugar Ginger Maple Cookies
Samoas Pretzel Presents
And also including 2 other cookie recipes from your site:
Easy Slice ‘n’ Bake Vanilla Bean Christmas Sugar Cookies
FREEZER QUESTION: Of these five cookies, which ones freeze well? I’m not shipping until January 20th but just wanted to know if I could make any of these ahead of time (like now-ish). If any can be frozen, do I have to let them sit out in room temperature and defrost before bagging them up or can they be bagged and packaged straight from the freezer? Just worried about condensation.
CHOCOLATE QUESTION: How would you package the Samoas? I was planning on putting them all in one cookie bag but will that cause them to melt? Should I try to package each one in its own individual cookie bag?
RANDOM QUESTION: I was looking for a red velvet cookie recipe but couldn’t find one on your site. Do you think if I added a natural plant-based food coloring to the CHRISTMAS MONSTER COOKIES they would turn out ok, taste and looks wise?
Thank you for your time and any other tips with these cookies is greatly appreciated!
Thanks so much for your kind message and reaching out! How fun you are going to make your first cookie box. You can really freeze any of those cookies, they will be just fine. I would wrap the Samoas in parchment or wax paper. I probably wouldn’t add food coloring to the monster cookies, tat wouldn’t really make them red velvet anyways:) Let me know if you have any other questions! Best of luck! xTieghan
Thanks for your feedback Tieghan! I appreciate you taking the time to answer my questions!
One more question (for now haha): For the cookies that have frosting, can I freeze them with frosting or is it better to freeze without?
Thank you again in advance!
I would freeze without the frosting and add that when you are ready to ship:)
I made my cookie box and I think it was a huge success!! However, I’ve run into delivery issues with the post office 🙁
I made all of my cookies Thursday (1/20) and packed them up nicely. I shipped them out Friday morning (1/22) and paid for one-day delivery, expecting them to arrive Saturday (1/22).
Unfortunately, the cookies aren’t arriving to it’s destination until later today (Monday 1/24). My questions is how long does my boyfriend have to consume these cookies this week given they’re arriving 4 days after they were baked? *Also does he still have an opportunity to freeze them and eat them sometime later?
As a reminder I made your Monster Cookies, Brown Sugar Ginger Maple Cookies
and Samoas Pretzel Presents!
Thanks in advance for any advice!
So sorry to hear this, the post office is never reliable in my experience. I would say he should eat them within 2 days or freeze them. I hope this helps! xTieghan
Thanks, Tieghan! I’m 63 years old and have bake Christmas cookies all my life with my mom. It is a special tradition that we looked forward to and thoroughly enjoyed. (My friends and family look forward to it every year as well.) Sadly, I lost my mom in early 2018 and missed baking cookies in 2017… mom was too sick and I was exhausted. But began again in 2018, talking to my mom the whole time. We always made about 10 varieties and, like you, some have stood the test of time while others come and go. Thank you for sharing this post and your recipes. I just finished my baking for this year but will check back with you next year and try some of your cookies. Also thanks for the cookie container links! Very helpful. Merry Christmas!
Thank you so much for sharing your thoughtful message. I love hearing your baking stories, and so sorry to hear about your mom. Wishing you a wonderful Christmas! xTieghan
OMG, I am drooling already! One year we made 25 different cookies/candies to share. My parents now bake together, so I’m going to hopefully send the link to them.
Thanks so much Shelley!
I just came across this post on the day I was planning to put my list together for what cookies we will bake. You have definitely made the list longer and harder fir jr to decide what to bake – and I haven’t looked at the previous years. I definitely need to make spritz cookies since they remind me of my childhood baking with my mother. The little Santa’s and the molasses ones will be on the list. Thank you for sharing this.
I hope you love the recipes Sally! xTieghan
I make a cookie box with your recipes every year!! They are adorable and delicious! I especially love the Santa and ginger ones 🙂 Thanks again for another great year, Happy Holidays!!
Awe thanks so much Stephanie, I love to hear this! Happy Holidays! xTieghan
What is the size of your box in the main pic? Looking to recreate!!!
It’s probably 8×10, but you can make these boxes any size you like! xx
If u r shipping UPS beware of stamping FRAGILE on the box, it added another $24 in shipping costs to a package that was shipped to me.
Thanks for sharing Kacy!
This looks beautiful and I love those Christmas light cookies so much! Is it possible for you to post a photo of what the box packaged for shipping look like? It’s always a bummer when you spend so much time making all the things and then package it up and it looks nothing like the photos in the post you followed.
So sorry, I do not have any photos of the packaging, but like I noted above, wrapping in bubble wrap really helps! xTieghan
Thank you for compiling all these tips and generously sharing your recipes! Merry Christmas to you and your wonderful family!
Do you sell these cookies and can it be shipped to China? I really don’t care when it’s going to arrive tbh. They just look amazing and I’d love to surprise my GF there. I’m located in Saudi Arabia now.
What about those chocolate dipped pretzels? Any special recipe for those? They look amazing!
Just pretzels dipped in chocolate:) xTieghan
So sorry, these boxes are not for sale:) Happy Holidays! xTieghan
Happy to share Penni! Merry Christmas! xTieghan
do you sell these cookie boxes ? I would love to buy them…
So sorry, these boxes are not for sale:) Happy Holidays! xTieghan