Next Post
Soft and Crinkly Brown Sugar Peanut Butter Cookies.
This post may contain affiliate links, please see our privacy policy for details.
Quick cooking Lemon Garlic Butter Shrimp Special…a fun meal to enjoy any night of the week. Seasoned with paprika and cayenne pepper, then tossed in a lemon butter sauce with crisp caramelized garlic. Every last shrimp has just the right amount of heat, lemon, butter, and crispy garlic. Serve this shrimp up with mounds of steamed rice and a creamy lemon pepper sauce for dipping. Simply add a couple of pineapple wedges on the side for a truly tropical feel. And if you really love sauce…do a double-dip with a sweet and spicy chili sauce. Trust me, it’s beyond GOOOD.
Anyone else slowly starting to dream up that topical spring vacation? I’ve hit that point in the winter when I want nothing more than a trip to Florida for some warmth and sunshine. Anyone else?
When I was growing up, my family would travel to Florida every Easter. I’m longing for one of those trips right now! So instead I’ve been thinking about all the places I’m excited to travel to once traveling is “normal” again. Since traveling is still difficult right now, or at least out of the country is, I figured a fun dinner inspired by a tropical destination is exactly what we all need.
Enter this shrimp, it feels very fresh and topical. The fun part is that we can all make this at home, and pretty darn easily too!
This shrimp was very much inspired by the shrimp you’ll find on the North Shore of Oahu, Hawaii. It’s served up at the local food trucks, one of the more popular being Giovanni’s Shrimp Truck. If you’ve been lucky enough to travel to Hawaii, hopefully you’ve experienced the famous garlic shrimp. After reading about Giovanni’s shrimp, it sounded way too delicious. I knew I wanted to try and create a homemade version.
The funny thing is that I’ve actually shared a similar recipe years ago inspired by the famous Hawaiian garlic shrimp, but I wanted to give it another try as I didn’t love my original recipe. So here we are. There seem to be a lot of recipes for this specific shrimp online, each varying from the other just slightly. I read Giovanni’s menu, looked through photos on Pinterest, and tried to find as much info I could before diving into creating the recipe.
The most popular trucks are Giovanni’s Shrimp Truck and Romy’s Kahuku Prawns & Shrimp. If you’re visiting, both trucks are worth stopping in for some shrimp. I used Giovanni’s as more of my inspiration. Again, this is just my take, I’m sure it’s not exactly how they make their shrimp by any means.
The key is using shell-on shrimp, which adds so much flavor to the dish. Some people like to eat the entire shrimp, shell and all. While others prefer to suck the sauce off then remove the shell and eat. I still can’t quite get fully on board with eating the shell, so I cooked half the shrimp with shell on/tail on, and the other half, shell off. It gives you all the wonderful flavors and mix of shrimp to enjoy. But you can do whatever you prefer, of course.
And don’t forget to devein your shrimp. I’ve made this mistake before, so putting out a friendly reminder for you guys!
Once you have the shrimp all prepped, toss them into a mix of paprika and cayenne. I like to go heavy on both spices, but make sure to use the cayenne pepper to your taste.
Pan sear the shrimp in olive oil until crisp on both sides, then pull it out of the skillet and cook the garlic and butter. The trick here is to slowly caramelize the garlic in the butter. You need to be careful not to burn the garlic. Instead, you want the garlic to turn deep golden in color and become crisp. It happens quickly so keep an eye on it to ensure it doesn’t burn.
As soon has you have the garlic crisp, toss in more butter and add the shrimp back, tossing it with all that butter. At this point, just squeeze over lots of lemon juice…beyond delicious. The shrimp is a little spicy, perfectly buttery, and that garlic…well it just seals the deal. It’s rich, caramelized, and just ever so slightly crispy.
Of course, these sauces are not traditional. You can make them both or simply make the shrimp. But you know that over here we love sauce, so the more the better.
The creamy lemon pepper sauce adds just the right amount of creamy tang, but the chili sauce adds a sweet and spicy element. Both are delicious and pair wonderfully with the shrimp. Again, make one, both, or neither…though I do recommend both!
Be sure to serve each plate of shrimp with steamed rice and lemon wedges. Then add the sauces and spoon over any leftover lemon butter from the pan.
If you’re in need of a little reprieve from winter, this is the perfect tropical-inspired dinner! Hope you guys love this one as much as we do!
Nutritional information is only an estimate. The accuracy of the nutritional information for any recipe on this site is not guaranteed.
This was so delicious!! I cut the butter back a bit just for calorie sake. I was actually going to take a picture and post but everyone dug in to quick.
Hey Kim,
I am thrilled this recipe was enjoyed, thanks a lot for making it! Happy Sunday! xTieghan
Looks good! Can you use frozen shrimp?
Thanks Stella! Yes, frozen shrimp will work just fine. I hope you love the recipe! xTieghan
Made this yummy recipe this evening and both sauces. May husband and I really enjoyed it and marveled at how the garlic was not overwhelming. I was a little partial to the lemony pepper sauce. We love the bold flavors and appreciate all your culinary ideas.
Hey Janeese,
I am thrilled this recipe was enjoyed, thanks a lot for making it! Happy Sunday! xTieghan
Absolutely fantastic!! Will definitely make again, thank you!!
Hey Kim,
I am thrilled this recipe was enjoyed, thanks a lot for making it! Happy Sunday! xTieghan
Made it! Delicious
Thanks so much Micaela! xTieghan
Amazing!
Thanks Rebecca! xTieghan
Oh my goodness. I knew when this popped in my email I’d be making it soon and I just made it. I decided that since I had both types of paprika I’d use them both. I am not a fan of lemon with my seafood, but I love lime so I used that instead. And for the sauce, instead of using plain honey and cayenne, I used a spiced hot honey. So good, so easy and it will be made again. Thanks.
Hey Jody,
I am thrilled this recipe was enjoyed, thanks a lot for making it! Happy Sunday! xTieghan
In reading this, I’d suggest cutting the shell down the back, allowing cleaning of the shrimp, thus retaining the shells for the full flavor, but also allowing for the sauce to seep under the shell. I agree with you, I tried eating the shell once. Nope, not again.
Thanks Jules! xTieghan
This looks amazing! I completely understand about how the shells bring the flavor, but for those who want a less messy eating experience, do you have suggestions on how to use the shells in the sauce but not leave them the shrimp?
Hey Laura,
I would just recommend following the recipe as is and then peeling the shrimp when you are ready to eat. I hope you love the recipe, please let me know if you have any other questions! xTieghan
This looks amazing! Your recipes are always so creative! What is the chili sauce?
Thanks so much Cate! The recipe for the chili sauce is listed above under the recipe notes. I hope you love the dish! xTieghan
This looks so good! If I wanted to add a vegetable to the dish what would you recommend?
Hey Marie,
I would serve this with white rice and your fave veggie on the side. I hope you love the recipe, please let me know if you have any other questions! xTieghan
For someone that has visited Gionanni’s many times, the shrimp is just so darn delicious. This recipe is not the same but still looks delicious. Chickens and old cats were running around and shrimp on paper plates made it very memorable. The shrimp had a little more sauce. I loved the recipe from your cookbook but will tweak it a bit to mirror this recipe here. Can’t wait to try it! I hope you get to visit this amazing place in Hawaii sometime.
I hope you love the recipe Scarlett! xTieghan
Omg yum!!! I’m living on Oahu right now and will make sure to 1) cook these up and 2) visit those trucks. Who knew I’d get some Hawaii recs on HBH!! Thanks for sharing, and I’ll give both a proper taste test ?
I hope you love the recipe Maggie!! xTieghan
I opened up the link and I could tell immediately what kind of shrimp you were trying to emulate. They look just like mine and my husband’s favorite shrimp from the shrimp truck on the North Shore. I’m excited to make them this weekend to see how close they taste!
Hope you love the recipe Megan! xTieghan
will be making this soon with few suvs will dm you if i make this soon and let you know how it goes Thanks Ramya
Thanks Ramya! xTieghan