Next Post
Spicy Chickpea and Cheese Stuffed Zucchini.
This post may contain affiliate links, please see our privacy policy for details.
Tuesday’s require something fun, enter these Homemade Animal Crackers. Lightly sweetened baked animal crackers with sweet honey, vanilla, and hints of cinnamon throughout. Each mini animal cracker is dipped into a berry-colored glaze for a fun (natural) finish and a snack that takes us all back to being a kid again. There’s nothing not to love about these crackers. Perfect for both a Tuesday afternoon or a weekend baking project. Or even just when you need a deliciously sweet and incredibly fun cracker to snack on.
Aren’t these so sweet? Almost dainty like, right? They’re probably the most fun cracker to both bake up and eat. I love the fact that these take me back to being 10 years old with not a care in the world…other than what was on the agenda for my summer. Sounds so nice, right?
These crackers take you back to that carefree mindset. Not only that but they’re so darn delicious. Sweet, but not overly sugary, soft, but with a little cracker-like crunch. Then finished with the sweetest, all-natural, no die berry-filled glazed.
Summer cracker perfection. I could not love these animals more.
Truth is that I’ve been wanting to try my hand at homemade animal crackers for years. Every time I thought about baking them though, I never had the right cookie cutter. I finally bought this cute cookie cutter set and last weekend Asher and I made homemade animal crackers. It took us an entire Sunday, BUT it was the perfect summer baking project to keep her laughing, snacking, and having fun.
I could not think of a better way to spend a stormy summer weekend day than baking animal crackers with my favorite little sister. Asher’s been bored out of her mind since school got out. So she’s been spending time with me at the studio lending a helping hand in the kitchen. As mentioned in Sunday’s favorites post, she’s actually been a huge help, but these crackers were all about having fun. It was the perfect easy baking project that Asher could mostly do all on her own.
So, if you have young kids that are bored this summer, bake these crackers with them. They’re easy, so fun to create, and even better to enjoy once baked and frosted.
So, what exactly is an animal cracker made up of?
Honestly, it’s just a simple glazed sugar cookie. Nothing fancy, but yet we all love them so much. I wanted to make these crackers more of a snack and less of an all-out dessert. So I used only a touch of brown sugar and a squeeze of honey. I won’t go as far as saying these are health food. But when compared to the store-bought variety, these crackers are much healthier…and so much better tasting too.
Meaning, these crackers have flavor and texture!! YESS.
The dough is a simple sugar cookie dough, but it’s flavored throughout with honey, vanilla, and cinnamon. Not classic in an animal cracker, but you guys, trust me, these flavors are GOOD. They take boring tasting animals crackers to DELICIOUS and ADDICTING. So add the flavors.
Now, once you have the dough made, roll it out and cut into your favorite animal shapes. Again, I used this cookie cutter set, but you can use whatever your heart (or you kids) desire. Just be sure to keep the shapes all similar in size so that they bake up evenly together. Our favorite animals were the elephants and dolphins, but we really wish we would’ve had a lion.
For the glaze, I knew I wanted to color it, but I also knew I wanted to steer clear of food coloring. It’s always something that has freaked me out a bit, because like, what on earth is it really, you know?
Instead of food coloring, I ended up using in-season berries to color the glaze, and it turned out SO CUTE. In love with the dainty pink, purple, and grey/blue colors we got using the juice from strawberries, blackberries, and blueberries.
Not only did the berries color the glaze, but they added a very subtle berry flavor. Both Asher and I found the berry glaze to be the perfect balance to the cinnamony crackers.
If sprinkles are your thing, top with your favorites. They do add a cute factor, but personally, we much prefer our crackers au naturel.
Highly recommend baking these crackers if you need to destress. Or if you need to entertain your kids. Or if you just need to feel 10 years old again and enjoy some animal crackers and re-runs of Friends.
Either which way, just make these soon. They do take a few minutes to make, but they’re so easy, beyond delicious and the most fun way to spend an afternoon…
Serious question: did you eat animal crackers growing up? My mom would occasionally buy the unfrosted crackers, but honestly, I don’t remember eating them much. How about you guys?
If you make these homemade animal crackers, be sure to leave a comment and/or give this recipe a rating! Above all, I love to hear from you guys and always do my best to respond to each and every comment. And of course, if you do make this recipe, don’t forget to tag me on Instagram! Looking through the photos of recipes you all have made is my favorite!
Nutritional information is only an estimate. The accuracy of the nutritional information for any recipe on this site is not guaranteed.
My three year old and I had such a fun time making these! And they were delicious! Also using berries in replace of food coloring was genius and we loved it!
Thank you so much Fayth! xTieghan
We loved these! Not too sweet and fun to do with my 2 year old granddaughter. I’ll post pics on Instagram and tag HBH?
We loved these! Not too sweet and fun to do with my 2 year old granddaughter. I’ll post pics on Instagram and tag HBH?
Can’t wait to check them out! So glad you enjoyed this Susan! xTieghan
These are incredible! Can I freeze the dough for a few days to make as a mid-week treat?
I love all your recipes-keep up the AMAZING work!
Hey Rita! Yes, you can certainly freeze the dough, that works so well! Just thaw overnight in the fridge OR thaw on the counter for a couple of hours before rolling. Please let me know if you have any other questions. I hope you love this recipe! Thank you! xTieghan
Hi there – these are so cute!! Do you think it’d work to make the dough the night before and leave in the refrigerator to roll out the next day? Thank you!!
Hey Kaylee! That works very well! Just let the dough soften for 5 minutes at room temp before rolling. Please let me know if you have any other questions. I hope you love this recipe! Thank you! xTieghan
I love these and love the idea of coloring the icing naturally!
This recipe looks AMAZING!
However, my son is allergic to eggs. Any ideas on a substitute that might work?
Thanks for all of your delicious recipes!
Hi there! Have you ever used a flax or chia egg? I would recommend starting with one of those. I think it might work really well. Please let me know if you have any other questions. I hope you love this recipe! Thank you! xTieghan
Oh and it’s a great excuse to buy more cookie cutters too, Thanks!!!
Wow I can’t wait for a free day to try this, I have several tiny cookie cutters from the doggie treats I make. Thanks for a cute recipe.
So perfect!! And that is so sweet that you make little dog treats! Yes! Thank you so much Bridget! xTieghan
These look awesome! Is this recipe in your book or just here? Is there a way I can when the recipes you post are in the book or only online? Thank you so much!
Hi Karissa! This recipe is just on my blog! The recipes in my book are completely different from the ones on my site! xTieghan
These are making me so nostalgic, Tieghssss!
RIGHT?! Hope you try these ones, Jane! Thank you! xTieghan
what a fun recipe with the added bonus of actually knowing what’s in the ingredient set (wow only 3 ingredients for the glaze, wonderful, thank you!
Yes! I love that part of making your own! I hope you try these, Sabrina! xTieghan
These animal crackers are adorable!! That sounds like such a fun time making these with Asher 🙂
It was the best! Thank you so much Sarah! xTieghan
Such a fun idea – I love these so much!! Thanks for sharing. 🙂
Thank you Lauren! I hope you try these! xTieghan
they’re so, so cute!!
Aren’t they?! So glad you like them! xTieghan